How to navigate a rise in unmeritorious claims

&

Unmeritorious claims are on the rise, clogging legal systems and HR inboxes, and exhausting resources. An employment lawyer shares recommendations to stem the flow of this issue further downstream.

Just this year, the Australian Human Rights Commission has seen a 162 per cent increase in unmeritorious claims which were declined or terminated due to a lack of substantive evidence behind them.

The Fair Work Commission also cited a 70 per cent increase in workload earlier this year, and AHRI’s September Quarterly Work Outlook report, exclusive to AHRI members, found that Australian organisations are reporting a 32 per cent increase in internal grievances and a 30 per cent increase in formal complaints or claims.

This sustained high caseload both inside organisations and within the legal system has resulted in lengthy delays in actioning complaints, which consequently impede on timely outcomes for employers and employees. 

Employment lawyer Emma Lutwyche, Partner at Pinsent Masons, explains some of the factors behind the sudden surge in unmeritorious claims – at an internal and external level – and outlines what employers can do to ensure employees are exhausting internal options before formalising their claims. 

What’s driving this increase in unmeritorious claims?

The uptick in claims is being observed by tribunals on an international level, and it can be attributed largely to increased AI usage, says Lutwyche.

“Someone who doesn’t have any background or understanding of the law can now prepare a lengthy and legally referenced – whether correct or not – written complaint [and] submit that to their employer.”

It can be incredibly difficult for someone without sufficient legal knowledge to decipher whether the AI-generated claim is valid, says Lutwyche.

These AI-generated claims can come with two significant issues:

  1. AI sycophancy – LLMs will generally give you the answer you want, regardless of the implications. “On the basis of employees asking, ‘Here’s what happened to me. Do I have a legal claim?’ It wants to tell you ‘yes’.”
  2. Hallucinations – Part and parcel of sycophancy, LLMs will often make up information to give users what they’re after. In this case, it might make up legal citations for an employee trying to build a claim.

So how should you respond to a claim you suspect is unmeritorious?

The first step should always be sitting down with the employee to understand their concern and determine the facts, says Lutwyche.

“Having a direct conversation is the best way to do that – talking to the employee about what’s really bothering them – because otherwise you are wading through pages of information,” says Lutwyche.

This helps bypass AI-embellished aspects of a submission and takes you straight to the substance of the complaint, she adds.

“This will be far more effective in identifying unmeritorious claims than engaging in protracted written back and forth with the employee.”

“Someone who doesn’t have any background or understanding of the law can now prepare a lengthy and legally referenced – whether correct or not – written complaint [and] submit that to their employer.” – Emma Lutwyche, Employment Lawyer and Partner at Pinsent Masons

Does the complaint warrant an investigation?

Sometimes, an investigation will be required before the employer can establish whether the complaint is unmeritorious or not.  

Once you have discussed the concerns with the employee and identified the substance of the complaint, employers should ask two questions to determine whether to investigate, says Lutwyche.

  • Is what this employee is raising capable of being a breach of policy, law misconduct, or a serious issue?

    If the answer is ‘no’, there may be no need for an investigation.

    A miscommunication, minor issue or complaint about reasonable management action that could not, even if substantiated, constitute a breach of law, policy or be misconduct, should not be investigated.

    For example, if an employee is disgruntled after being asked to do something that fits within the minimum requirements of their role, then you likely don’t need to investigate.
    “Investigating something that doesn’t need to be investigated will likely create the psychosocial hazards that can come from formalising a process unnecessarily and forcing participation in an investigation into something minor,” says Lutwyche.

    If the alleged conduct isn’t serious enough to warrant investigation, other avenues can be considered, such as informal mediation or providing increased clarity on roles or responsibilities.

  • Do you already have the evidence needed to take reasonable action?
    “You only investigate when you need to determine what the facts are… there’s no need to conduct an investigation into a [complaint] where you’ve got the facts,” says Lutwyche.

    For example, if the conduct complained of is the contents of an email, and you have a copy of the email, there is no need to commence a formal investigation, says Lutwyche.

    Importantly, a complaint that cannot be substantiated following investigation may not strictly be unmeritorious. To avoid further escalation by the complainant, Lutwyche says  it’s critical to tell them why it hasn’t been substantiated and look at whether there are steps that can be taken to address their concerns another way.

    Ensuring employees feel supported and satisfied with how their complaint has been dealt with, regardless of whether or not an investigation occurs, will reduce the chance of that employee then filing a complaint with an external body.

    However, if the factual findings of the investigation indicate that the claims were intentionally fabricated, false, retaliatory or vexatious, then a separate disciplinary process may need to be commenced against the complainant, she adds.

Consider procedural fairness

Dealing with all parties in a fair manner is crucial to reducing the risk that claims will escalate and to protecting psychosocial safety. 

Failing to manage complaints and grievances, regardless of merit, with procedural fairness can increase the risk that employees become disgruntled with how the employer handled the claim, and make it more likely they’ll make a complaint to a tribunal, court or other regulator, says Lutwyche.

This can look like following internal procedures for keeping complainants and those involved up to date on the investigation process, dealing with things in a timely and structured manner, maintaining confidentiality, and dealing with matters consistently and fairly, she says.

“While it may seem counter-intuitive, having multiple robust complaint and reporting mechanisms, and grievance policies and procedures which focus on informal resolution at the internal stage, is critical.” – Emma Lutwyche, Employment Lawyer and Partner at Pinsent Masons 

Unmeritorious complaints in the FWC 

Over recent months, there have been examples of the FWC being strict on employees bringing forward claims that have no substance or merit.

In one FWC case, an employee who was dismissed three days short of the six-month minimum employment period filed an unfair dismissal claim.

The applicant was found to have likely used AI extensively in his application, which included the phrase: “Here is your **final clean copy-paste version**, with today’s date inserted as the dismissal date.” The FWC also noted that the applicant’s likely AI-generated claim addressed the wrong question.

Before the scheduled hearing, he was advised by the FWC of the proper test under s.383 and told that, on his own version of events and his filed material, he was unlikely to succeed. He was invited to discontinue before the hearing, but continued with his unfair dismissal claim regardless.

Deputy President Easton said “using AI to help draft correspondence and submissions is not, of itself, unreasonable” and added that “artificial intelligence, in 2026 at least, is a drafting tool that can assist litigants when used properly.” 

However, he also found that the specific difficulties and cost consequences were explained to him in “clear and simple terms” and, as a result, the employee eventually conceded at the hearing and discontinued his application.

Following this, the FWC ordered the applicant to pay a sum of $1230 towards the employer’s legal costs. This is a seldom seen outcome in FWC cases, as the bar for ordering costs is very high. “In this case, the Commission was really making an example of the employee who had ignored… the facts before them, and just doubled down with AI,” says Lutwyche.

Preventing unmeritorious complaints 

The best way to prevent unmeritorious claims is to have a psychologically safe work environment, where employees are confident that genuine issues will be dealt with fairly and reasonably, says Lutwyche.

“While it may seem counter-intuitive, having multiple robust complaint and reporting mechanisms, and grievance policies and procedures which focus on informal resolution at the internal stage, is critical,” says Lutwyche.  Multiple options for managing matters internally, and employee confidence in the internal processes, will reduce the escalation of claims externally.

She recommends having contact people, anonymous complaint mechanisms and fostering a culture where employees are aware of bystander obligations and feel comfortable enough to speak up about behaviour they may have witnessed.

Additionally, where appropriate and with confidentiality upheld, safely sharing post-investigation outcomes within the business can enhance a culture where employees can feel confident that genuine grievances will be dealt with internally. 

While not all case outcomes and investigations can be shared, keeping employees informed when appropriate demonstrates that issues are taken seriously, and reminds employees of the behavioural expectations of the organisation.

It’s important to deal with concerns in real time. Not only is it more psychologically safe, but it also prevents things from festering and resulting in a more serious situation that has to be dealt with in a more formal manner.

All information, content and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. The contents of this article do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such.

🧰 HR’s career resource toolkit

RELATED CONTENT

Year-end brings a flood of workforce data and a growing compliance list. The sharpest HR leaders use Q4 differently: stepping back to spot the signals that will shape 2027 before January arrives.
Over a third of Australians say they’d put “less effort” into helping a leader succeed if they held different beliefs than they did.
Following a significant business growth period, how can you make sure your employee experience isn’t compromised? This People and Culture lead shares how her company kept its EX strategy in line with its strong growth, and raised employee wellbeing at the same time.